A Conversation: Can Free Markets Save American Medicine?

A recent article from the Mises Institute. “Under Socialized Medicine, The State Owns You,” sparked a conversation between Mr. Bob Wells and IP4PI founder Dr. Craig M. Wax.

Bob

I appreciate your assessment of the solutions presented like VA, Medicare and Medicaid being awkward, too expensive, and failing in large demonstrable ways. We haven’t had true market based medicine since World War II. Prior to that, it was relatively inexpensive cash and Barter based services. I argue this is the most efficient as it cuts out insurance, pharmacy benefits managers, all levels of administration, and last but not least, all aspects of government regulation compliance and taxation.

In the last six years there have been at least 12 plans on the table to repeal Obamacare. And, there have been six in the last 12 months. There was no sparsity of plans, just no palpable consensus.

I assert that inexpensive primary care, labs, low-end studies, cheap generic medications, will allow for most needs to be met by most people. And expanded health savings account HSA would be used for each citizen to use pretax dollars to buy anything health related from gym memberships to over the counter medications to actual care necessities. Further, inexpensive catastrophic insurance for the big ticket items would be also affordable by most. There could be community, charity, and state programs to provide for the neediest, while keeping the federal government taxation hands to itself.

Unless the Congress and President act soon to repeal Obamacare, just rearranging the deck chairs, will not prevent its fate. Already 19 out of 23 taxpayer-funded co-ops have gone bankrupt taking billions of taxpayer dollars with it. And for the phony federal mandates state exchanges, many have only one high price insurer participating, while still others have none. Leave it to the government to mandate you buy something very expensive and then there’s no opportunity to even comply!

Best wishes for good health,
Craig M. Wax, DO

—————

Dr. Wax,

The deficiencies of state-sponsored health care are widely known. What is difficult to figure out is an alternative — market-based — that is universally accessible and affordable (with affordability being as elastic as elastic can be), while still offering high quality. If there is a model in this world, I am unaware of it.

All efforts America has made to provide public support for health care since World War II, from the VA system to Medicare and Medicaid to Obamacare, have been awkward and grossly inefficient (if somewhat effective, overall). Unfortunately, blowing these systems up and starting a new system based solely on market forces would be catastrophic in the short term. And since politicians think in the short term, such a radical transformation is impossible.

Today’s Republicans realize there is reward in trashing Obamacare, but they also know that they do not have a better plan to replace it. If they really had a better plan they would have introduced it by now, and it would be on President Donald Trump’s desk for signature. The fact that they cannot agree among themselves on a replacement is testimony to how difficult a problem this is. (This does not excuse the Democrats, either.  They’d rather let the Republicans look foolish than offer their own “solutions.”)

Regards,

Bob Wells

Even a Seventh Grader Can Understand the Root Failure of Government-Run Care

From Steven Dailey FACHE:

The first term paper that I ever wrote was titled “Should Medicare and Medicaid Survive?” and was handed in to my seventh grade teach in the spring of 1967. She gave me a “B” because she did not believe that I had interviewed the local hospital administrator whom I quoted extensively in the term paper.

She also marked me down because in her mind, “our government never takes something away that they have already given away. That is just too hard to do.” Maybe she was right about never taking something away -. She was wrong about the interview with the hospital administrator – he was my Dad…. He ran a 500 bed hospital and he absolutely railed against the involvement of government in healthcare.

Many, many hospital administrators did not want Medicare and Medicaid back then. They knew all too well what would happen – regulation and cost increases year after year…. Isn’t it amazing that our public trusted our physicians and hospitals back in the 1960’s and after decades of increasing governmental regulation and trillions of government expenditures healthcare suddenly fails to meet public expectations? It isn’t amazing that when you add insurance coverage to tens of millions that costs will increase? Not really….

Real Patient Lives vs. Corporatized/Government Healthcare, Part IV

The insurance and government dominated system is failing our patients. A physician friend of IP4PI shares this shocking example about the system claiming another victim:

A 59 y/o man presented to my last employed practice, with an almost elephantiasis swelling bilateral legs.  He had pinpoint marks on the skin of his legs.  He held up a jar with what looked like a couple of tiny maggots.  He said, these come out of those holes every so often.  I said how long has this been going on??  He said 1.5 years.  “I’ve mentioned to several doctors, they just shrug and don’t do anything.”  I said we would do something, and called the hospitalist immediately to admit for workup and treatment.  I was directed to the nurse gatekeeper for approval for admission.  What’s wrong, she asked.  “4+ edema in both legs, which are also full of maggots.”  Hmmm, she said.  There is no medicare admissible diagnosis of ‘maggots in legs’.  What about his rising creatinine of 1.7?  Not bad enough to qualify under guidelines.  Call us back if it gets worse.  I did try to do some outpatient workup, but I think the man was disgusted.  He never followed up.  He was dead within the year.

Real Stories of the ACA nightmare #9 – A Tale of Two Patients

“Whereas Mr. Clinton has accurately diagnosed Obamacare’s fundamental problem, Mrs. Clinton has spent the past year either defending it or calling for even greater intervention in health care. Now momentum is building among her supporters and allies for a full-blown, single-payer system in which the government, using tax dollars, pays for all medical care of its choosing. Medicaid, Medicare and the Veterans Affairs hospital system operate on this model, and each provides sub-par care to their intended beneficiaries in many key ways…I have patients who show the dangers of going in this direction.

One patient comes from the VA. He requires very high doses of concentrated insulin to control his blood sugars. At my practice, we provided him with treatment quite effectively until he retired. Now the VA has been giving him the runaround for over six months. It has yet to even accept his application for the concentrated insulin he needs, which has driven his blood sugar to dangerous levels. It’s unclear when, or even if, the agency will get him the treatment he needs. His health is failing fast under the single-payer system.

The second patient is on Medicare. He has had type-1 diabetes for over 40 years, but thanks to advances in medicine he has been able to continue working on a consistent basis. When he turned 65 and went under Medicare, however, he lost his coverage for the specific treatment he needs. He has appealed this all the way up to a federal administrative law judge, but six months after the hearing he still hasn’t heard of a decision. His health, too, is failing fast.

Wouldn’t it have been better for these two men to keep their private insurance plans, which fit their needs and improved their health…My patients experience shows the danger of heading toward even greater government intervention in our health care system. If we empower bureaucrats to wield ever more power over patients’ health and well-being, the end result will be higher costs, fewer choices, worse care and even lost lives….For the sake of my patients, to say nothing of millions of other Americans, it’s critical that we get this one right.”

Valueless layers of bureaucrats crushing patients and doctors: it’s time to just bust out

Friend of IP4PI, Jack Iannantuono, writes in:

By taking over medicine in 1965 with Medicare the government had sown the seeds for the blood sucking, valueless layers of bureaucrats and regulations and Wall Street greedy hand and malpractice windfall in highway lining billboards with pictures of Physicians you will never see in person that now accounts for nearly 20 % of GDP about $3.3 trillion and I tell you truly health care can be delivered for less than a third of that…yes less than 1 trillion and be less than 5% of GDP and our physicians and communities would do it if we can just bust out of Washington trying to fix, reform or replace.

There is no need whatsoever for government to have a say or a place in medicine.

Obamacare turned from a nightmare into a weapon. Dang it …can we learn from this?

Jack Iannantuono, CFP®, ChFC®, MSFS, AIF® | Indicon, Inc.
Chief Executive Officer

Principles for individual healthcare freedom

Featured

IP4PI Physicians support the following resolutions for the legislative, executive and judicial branches of the US:

1.  The full repeal, nullification or reconciliation of ACA/Obamacare as it was:

A. Not passed by majority but buy a partisan Congress by reconciliation. B. Changed by the executive branch 43 times without appropriate congressional action. C. Changed by SCOTUS to be a tax bill. D. Tax bills must originate in the House and ACA originated in the Senate. E. ACA has changed healthcare from a professional physician-patient interaction into merely an act of government HHS/CMS unelected bureaucratic compliance. F. ACA lead to an uncontrolled rise in costs for all citizens through increased taxes, insurance costs, hospital costs, physician costs, use of narrow networks and severely limited ACA approved options. G. IRS and tax penalties for any American citizens violate the US Constitution. H. Mutually accepted individual customer-vendor purchases are the ideal way to allow personal choice, encourage excellence and establish price completion for best citizen consumer value. Continue reading

Eliminating The 6 Degrees of Patient-Physician Separation

Our Eliminating The 6 Degrees of Patient-Physician Separation article, penned by IP4PI founder Craig M. Wax, DO has been published at KevinMD.com!  Please check it out and leave your comments:

http://www.kevinmd.com/blog/2016/08/6-degrees-patient-physician-separation.html